3.1. Combustion Performance
Figure 4 illustrates the influence of diluent gases on combustion parameters under different cracked gas blending ratios. As shown in Figure 4, under the same dilution ratio and diluent gas, with the increase of cracked gas blending ratio, both the ignition delay period and combustion duration are shortened. Meanwhile, the effect of cracked gas blending on the combustion parameters of methanol engines is more significant when the diluent gas is CO2 compared with N2 and O2. Specifically, when the dilution ratio is 20% and the diluent is CO2, the effect of cracked gas blending on ignition delay period, combustion duration, and combustion center of gravity is the most obvious. At this time, compared with the cracked gas blending ratio of 0%, the ignition delay period and combustion duration at the blending ratio of 20% are shortened by 3.5 °CA and 13.5 °CA, respectively, and the combustion center of gravity is advanced by 8.5 °CA. This indicates that cracked gas blending can improve the combustion performance of methanol engines under different diluent gases. To verify the uniformity of the in-cylinder mixture, the spatial distribution of the equivalence ratio and the mole fractions of cracked gas components (H2 and CO) were analyzed at the spark timing.
Figure 4.
Effect of Diluent Gases on Combustion Performance of Cracked Gas Blended Engines.
Under the same dilution ratio and cracked gas blending ratio, when the diluent gas is CO2, the ignition delay period and combustion duration are shorter, and the combustion center of gravity is the most retarded, followed by N2 and O2. With the increase of dilution ratio, the influence of diluent gas on ignition delay period, combustion duration, and combustion center of gravity becomes more significant. Taking the cracked gas blending ratio of 0% as an example, when the dilution ratio is 10%, compared with O2, the ignition delay periods of CO2 and N2 are prolonged by 6.0 °CA and 2.6 °CA respectively, the combustion durations are prolonged by 14.6 °CA and 3.6 °CA respectively, and the combustion centers of gravity are advanced by 11.0 °CA and 4.5 °CA respectively. When the dilution ratio is 20%, the ignition delay periods are prolonged by 11.6 °CA and 3.0 °CA, respectively; the combustion durations are prolonged by 38.5 °CA and 5.6 °CA, respectively; and the combustion centers of gravity are advanced by 25.0 °CA and 5.0 °CA, respectively. In terms of in-cylinder specific heat capacity, the order is CO2 > N2 > O2. Meanwhile, CO2 is a product of the methanol combustion reaction and can inhibit the methanol reaction; N2 does not participate in the methanol combustion reaction, while O2 is a reactant of the methanol combustion reaction and can promote the reaction. Therefore, when the diluent gas is CO2, the ignition delay period and combustion duration are the shortest, and the combustion center of gravity is the most retarded, followed by N2 and O2. When the dilution ratio increases, the effect of diluent gas on combustion temperature and combustion reaction is enhanced; thus, the influence of diluent gas on ignition delay period, combustion duration, and combustion center of gravity becomes more obvious with the increase of dilution ratio.
Under the same diluent gas and cracked gas blending ratio, with the increase of dilution ratio, the ignition delay period and combustion duration are prolonged, and the combustion center of gravity is retarded. When the cracked gas blending ratio is 10%, for the diluent gases CO2, N2, and O2, the ignition delay periods at the dilution ratio of 20% are prolonged by 4.5 °CA, 0.5 °CA, and 0.2 °CA, respectively, compared with those at 10%. The combustion durations are prolonged by 18.5 °CA, 1.5 °CA, and 1.0 °CA, respectively, and the combustion centers of gravity are retarded by 15.0 °CA, 0.5 °CA, and 0.4 °CA, respectively. This is because with the increase of dilution ratio, the mass of in-cylinder working fluid increases, resulting in the decrease of combustion temperature and combustion speed. Therefore, the ignition delay period and combustion duration are prolonged, and the combustion center of gravity is retarded.
Figure 5 shows the effect of diluent gases on the in-cylinder pressure of cracked gas blended engines. Under the same dilution ratio and diluent gas, with the increase of cracked gas blending ratio, the peak in-cylinder pressure increases and the corresponding crankshaft angle advances. Taking a dilution ratio of 10% as an example, when the diluent gases are CO2, N2, and O2, the peak in-cylinder pressure at a cracked gas blending ratio of 20% increases by 0.85 MPa, 0.45 MPa, and 0.43 MPa, respectively, compared with that at 0%. Since cracked gas blending can affect combustion processes under all three diluent gases, it can also increase the peak in-cylinder pressure for these three gases.
Figure 5.
Effect of Diluent Gases on In-Cylinder Pressure of Cracked Gas Blended Engines.
Under the same dilution ratio and cracked gas blending ratio, the peak in-cylinder pressure follows the order: O2 > N2 > CO2. Taking a dilution ratio of 10% and a cracked gas blending ratio of 10% as an example, the peak in-cylinder pressure of O2 and N2 is 1.5 MPa and 0.9 MPa higher than that of CO2 respectively. This is because when CO2 is used as the diluent gas, the ignition delay period and combustion duration are the short, and the combustion center of gravity is the most retarded, followed by N2 and O2.
At the same cracked gas blending ratio, when CO2 is the diluent gas, the peak in-cylinder pressure decreases with the increase of dilution ratio. However, when N2 and O2 are the diluent gases, the peak in-cylinder pressure increases slightly as the dilution ratio rises. Taking a cracked gas blending ratio of 20% as an example, for diluent gases CO2, N2, and O2, the peak in-cylinder pressure at a dilution ratio of 20% decreases by 1.24 MPa, increases by 0.02 MPa, and increases by 0.07 MPa respectively compared with that at 10%. When CO2 is the diluent gas, the increase in dilution ratio leads to a significant prolongation of the ignition delay period and combustion duration, thus resulting in a decrease in peak in-cylinder pressure. In contrast, the increase in dilution ratio has little effect on the ignition delay period and combustion duration when N2 and O2 are used as diluent gases. Meanwhile, the increase in dilution ratio leads to an increase in the mass of in-cylinder working fluid. Therefore, when N2 and O2 are the diluent gases, the increase in dilution ratio causes a slight rise in peak in-cylinder pressure.
Constant volume specific heat capacity refers to the heat required for a unit mass of substance to raise its temperature by 1 K under the condition of constant volume. During the combustion process of spark-ignition engines, the in-cylinder volume change is small, so constant volume specific heat capacity is an important factor affecting the in-cylinder combustion temperature. Figure 6 shows the effect of diluent gases on the constant volume specific heat capacity of cracked gas blended engines. It can be seen from the figure that in the initial stage of the ignition process, the constant volume specific heat capacity increases with the increase of the cracked gas blending ratio, which is due to the fact that the constant volume specific heat capacity of cracked gas is higher than that of methanol. For different diluent gases, it can be seen that the effect of diluent gases on the constant volume specific heat capacity is small; it is basically the same when the dilution ratio is 10%, while O2 is slightly lower than CO2 and N2 when the dilution ratio is 20%. Therefore, it can be determined that from the perspective of physical properties, the effects of the three gases on the in-cylinder combustion temperature are significantly different. Comparing the constant volume specific heat capacity of the in-cylinder gas under different dilution ratios, it is found that the constant volume specific heat capacity is also not significantly different with the increase of the dilution ratio.
Figure 7 shows the effect of diluent gases on the total mass of in-cylinder working fluid of cracked gas blended engines. Under the same volume dilution ratio, the total mass of in-cylinder working fluid with CO2 as the diluent gas is greater than that with O2, which is greater than that with N2. At the same time, the total mass of in-cylinder working fluid increases with the increase of the dilution ratio. From the perspective of physical properties, the inhibition of in-cylinder temperature by diluent gases and dilution ratio mainly comes from the increase of in-cylinder working fluid mass rather than the properties of diluent gases.
Figure 6.
Effect of Diluent Gases on Constant Volume Specific Heat Capacity of Cracked Gas Blended Engines.
Figure 7.
Effect of Diluent Gases on Total Mass of In-Cylinder Working Fluid of Cracked Gas Blended Engines.
Figure 8 shows the effect of diluent gases on the in-cylinder temperature of cracked gas blended engines. Under the same dilution ratio and diluent gas, with the increase of the cracked gas blending ratio, the peak in-cylinder temperature rises and the corresponding crankshaft angle advances. Taking a dilution ratio of 10% as an example, when the diluent gases are CO2, N2, and O2, the peak in-cylinder temperature increases by 237 K, 127 K, and 154 K, respectively. This is because although the blending of cracked gas leads to an increase in the constant volume specific heat capacity of the in-cylinder working fluid, it is obvious that the acceleration of combustion rate caused by cracked gas blending is more significant. Therefore, cracked gas blending can result in an increase in the peak in-cylinder temperature.
Under the same dilution ratio and cracked gas blending ratio, the peak in-cylinder temperature follows the order: O2 > N2 > CO2. Taking a dilution ratio of 10% and a cracked gas blending ratio of 10% as an example, the peak in-cylinder temperature of O2 and N2 is 243 K and 380 K higher than that of CO2, respectively. This is because the effect of diluent gases on the constant volume specific heat capacity is small, but when CO2 is used as the diluent gas, the ignition delay period and combustion duration are the shortest, and the combustion center of gravity is the most retarded, followed by N2 and O2. In this study, methanol is directly injected into the cylinder using a high-pressure direct injection system. Specifically, the cracked gas is supplied from high-pressure cylinders and injected into the intake manifold via a dedicated electronically controlled gas injector, where it mixes with the intake air before entering the cylinder. Similarly, the dilution gases are introduced into the intake manifold through a separate injection system and are premixed with the intake air upstream of the intake port. To ensure mixture homogeneity, the injection of cracked gas and dilution gases is continuously controlled during the intake stroke, allowing sufficient time for mixing with the intake air before entering the cylinder. The intake manifold is designed to promote turbulent mixing, and the in-cylinder flow field further enhances mixture uniformity during the compression stroke. This configuration ensures that the cracked gas and dilution gases are uniformly distributed in the cylinder before combustion.
Figure 8.
Effect of Diluent Gases on In-Cylinder Temperature of Cracked Gas Blended Engines.
2.2. Emission Performance and Sources
Figure 9 shows the effect of diluent gases on the NOX emissions of cracked gas blended engines. As shown in Figure 9a, under the same dilution ratio and cracked gas blending ratio, the NOX increase emissions follow the order: CO2 < N2 < O2. Taking a cracked gas blending ratio of 10% and a dilution ratio of 10% as an example, the NOX emissions of CO2 and N2 are 98.5% and 89.3% lower than that of O2, respectively. This is mainly attributed to the difference in in-cylinder combustion temperature, where the combustion temperature of CO2 is lower than that of N2, which is lower than that of O2. The cracked gas used in this study is a hydrogen-rich gas produced by catalytic cracking of methanol. It was not generated online during engine operation but was obtained from a separate methanol cracking experimental setup. The composition of the cracked gas was maintained consistent across all simulation conditions.
Figure 9.
Effect of Diluent Gases on NOX Emissions of Cracked Gas Blended Engines.
As shown in Figure 9b, under the same CA50, comparing the engine NOX emissions of different diluent gases, it is found that the NOX emissions of O2 are significantly higher than those of CO2 and N2, while the difference between CO2 and N2 is small. The CA50 and NOX emissions are basically the same under the conditions of CO2 with a dilution ratio of 10% and a cracked gas blending ratio of 20%, and N2 with a dilution ratio of 20% and a cracked gas blending ratio of 10%. However, when the dilution ratio is 10%, the CA50 is basically the same for O2 with a cracked gas blending ratio of 0% and N2 with a cracked gas blending ratio of 20%, but the NOX emissions differ greatly. This is because O2 directly participates in the formation reaction of NOX, and the increase in O2 promotes the generation of NOX emissions. It is worth noting that when the cracked gas blending ratio is 0%, and O2 is the diluent gas, the CA50 changes slightly as the dilution ratio increases from 10% to 20%, while the NOX emissions show a slight downward trend. Once beyond this range, the further promoting effect of continuing to increase the dilution ratio on NOX emissions is obviously weakened.
An optimized application analysis of the cracked gas blending ratio and diluent gas is carried out for Figure 9b. It can be seen that under the same dilution ratio and cracked gas blending ratio, CO2 achieves the optimal NOX emissions, and N2 achieves the coordinated optimization of NOX emissions and combustion performance.
Figure 10 shows the effect of diluent gases on the CO emissions of cracked gas blended engines. Under different diluent gases, the influence of the law of cracked gas blending on engine CO emissions varies. When O2 is the diluent gas, cracked gas blending can significantly reduce CO emissions, while the effect is opposite when N2 and CO2 are used as diluent gases. Specifically, at a dilution ratio of 10%, with CO2, N2, and O2 as diluent gases, respectively, the CO emissions at a cracked gas blending ratio of 20% increase by 51.4%, 53.0%, and decrease by 84.2% compared with those at 0%. Figure 11 shows the effect of diluent gases on the in-cylinder CO formation region distribution of cracked gas blended engines. The results indicate that there are significant differences in the CO distribution regions under different diluent gases. When N2 and CO2 are the diluent gases, the in-cylinder CO distribution region is relatively wide, while when O2 is the diluent gas, CO is mainly distributed in the wall region. This suggests that when N2 and CO2 are used as diluent gases, CO emissions are mainly affected by the distribution of rich and lean fuel regions in the cylinder, while under O2 dilution, the CO formation region is similar to that of HC emissions. Therefore, as the cracked gas blending ratio increases, the base amount of in-cylinder CO increases, leading to a rise in CO emissions when N2 and CO2 are the diluent gases. In contrast, when O2 is the diluent gas, the in-cylinder combustion temperature increases, resulting in a decrease in CO emissions.
A further comparison of CO emissions under different diluent gases reveals that the engine CO emissions with O2 as the diluent gas are much lower than those with N2 and CO2. At a dilution ratio of 10%, the CO emission levels of CO2 and N2 are similar, but when the dilution ratio increases to 20%, the CO emissions with CO2 as the diluent gas are significantly higher than those with N2. This is because the cylinder is in an oxygen-rich state when O2 is the diluent gas; the engine CO emissions with O2 are much lower than those with N2 and CO2. When N2 and CO2 are the diluent gases, CO emissions are mainly affected by the in-cylinder combustion temperature. At a dilution ratio of 10%, the combustion temperatures under the two diluent gases are not significantly different, leading to similar CO emission levels. However, when the dilution ratio increases to 20%, CO2 dilution causes obvious combustion deterioration due to excessively slow combustion speed and significantly reduced combustion temperature, which in turn triggers a sharp rise in CO emissions. It is worth noting that when N2 and O2 are the diluent gases, the CO emissions change gently with the increase of the dilution ratio. But when CO2 is the diluent gas, the CO emissions increase significantly as the dilution ratio rises. This indicates that when the combustion temperature and speed drop below a certain threshold, CO emissions will increase sharply.
Figure 10.
Effect of Diluent Gases on CO Emissions of Cracked Gas Blended Engines.
Figure 11.
Effect of Diluent Gases on the Distribution of In-Cylinder CO Formation Regions of Cracked Gas Blended Engines.
Figure 12 and Figure 13 show the effects of diluent gases on HC emissions and unconventional emissions under different cracked gas blending ratios, respectively. Studies have shown that regardless of the type of diluent gas used, blending cracked gas can effectively reduce HC, CH3OH, and CH2O emissions. At a dilution ratio of 20%, with CO2, N2, and O2 as diluent gases respectively, the HC emissions at a cracked gas blending ratio of 20% are reduced by 58.7%, 66.3%, and 86.8% compared with those at 0%; the CH3OH emissions are reduced by 59.0%, 66.0%, and 86.9% respectively; and the CH2O emissions are reduced by 54.8%, 73.9%, and 83.8% respectively. This is mainly because cracked gas blending can increase the in-cylinder combustion temperature, thereby weakening the wall quenching effect and further reducing HC, CH3OH, and CH2O emissions.
Further analysis reveals that there are differences in the effects of diluent gases on HC and unconventional emissions. Comparing the effects of different diluent gases on HC and unconventional emissions, the emission levels follow the order: O2 < N2 < CO2. This result is related to the changes in in-cylinder combustion temperature caused by different diluent gases. At the same time, as the dilution ratio increases, both HC and unconventional emissions increase. This is because the in-cylinder combustion temperature decreases with the increase of the dilution ratio.
Figure 12.
Effect of Diluent Gases on HC Emissions of Cracked Gas Blended Engines.
Figure 13.
Effect of Diluent Gases on Unconventional Emissions Under Different Cracked Gas Blending Ratios.